Dispelling nutrition myths, ranting, and occasionally, raving

Which fitness tracker gives you the best calories burned for your workout? An experiment

5 Comments

20170507_195119

Remember my rant a little while ago about how you shouldn’t think of exercise and food as an equation to balance? Or my post about not using the exercise component of calorie counting apps? Well, I just wanted to add a little more to that conversation today.

I use a Garmin watch to track my runs and occasionally I’ll look at the “calories burned” out of curiosity. After a pretty fast longish interval run I noticed that the calories burned seemed rather low so I started scrolling back through and was puzzled to find a shorter easier run that supposedly resulted in a very similar caloric expenditure. That left me wondering how Garmin determined the calories burned during a run. I looked it up and it turns out that it’s related to heart rate. Sometime the heart rate monitor is wonky and (especially when it’s really cold out) will register a heart rate that would be more likely seen when I’m sitting on my butt than when I’m out booking it through speed work. That means that my Garmin (erroneously) registers minimal exertion and thinks that I’m not burning very many calories.

Today I decided to do a little experiment. I wore my Garmin, as per usual, which is synched to my Strava account. I also fired up the Nike+ Run Club app for the first time in ages and I set out on an easy(ish) 10k run. After the run, I also entered the time spent running at the closest average pace into myfitnesspal. All of these apps have my height and weight. Any guesses what the results looked like?

Garmin: 463 calories

myfitnesspal: 517 calories

Nike: 526 calories

Strava: 1371 calories!!!!

Now, I have no idea how many calories I actually used during this run, I’d wager Garmin was probably closest to the mark considering that the heart rate monitor seemed to be working properly. But Strava, what the actual hell?? Considering that Strava gets all of it’s data from my run directly from Garmin I find it amazing that it estimated I burned nearly three times as many calories as Garmin thought I did. I’m sure that if I had other apps and trackers I would have gotten slightly different results from all of them.

All this to say, if you’re exercising and tracking calories burned, you probably shouldn’t give that number too much weight. Try to think of exercise as giving you health and fitness rather than taking away calories and weight.

 

Advertisements

Author: Diana

I'm a registered dietitian from Nova Scotia, living and working in Ontario, Canada. My goal is to help people relearn how to have a healthy relationship with food.

5 thoughts on “Which fitness tracker gives you the best calories burned for your workout? An experiment

  1. sometime long ago (likely in the 1980’s) and far away (St John’s), i got the estimate that 150 lb person uses about 100 calories per mile. This is just for the mechanical energy to move that mass that distance. It is probably for average running efficiency. Lighter runners would use less. More efficient runners would use less.

    There may be other factors like intensity that have some affect on actual calories used.

    Strava’s estimate is out to lunch (pun intended). The other numbers are sort of reasonable, depending on your mass.

    caveat – i am not a dietitian, physiologist or any kind of trained observer. heck, i can’t even spell dietitian without a spell-checker.

    run well, run happy
    george

    Like

  2. I’ve heard the same 100 cal per mile estimate – btw garmin still gives me a calorie burn estimate and I don’t have a heart rate monitor – maybe it really is just a guess based on weight and age – odd that strava gives a much higher estimate because it always shortens the distance. oh well, just keep running.

    Liked by 1 person

    • They just use what ever information is available to them so models that don’t have heart rate monitors just use your weight and distance and pace.

      Yes to just keeping on running!

      Like

  3. My mirror tracks my calories. As long as I’m eating healthy and exercising and keeping my (bedroom body) it’s all good.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s